Location: 8.13 Freedom

Discussion: Chat about episode 8.13 Freedom here!Reported This is a featured thread

Showing 41 - 60 of 144  |  Show  posts at a time
Previous | 1 2 3 4 5 | Next > Last
weatherlywatcher49
weatherlywatcher49
40. RE: Chat about episode 8.13 Freedom here!
Feb 2 2011, 1:17 AM EST | Post edited: Feb 2 2011, 1:17 AM EST
"You're right. It's this Tony-the-begging-dog/Ziva-the-tease-with-the-bone thing that bugs me too.

It's all done to tease the pubescent-teens (particularly the girls) but for series-watchers/analysts like me, it's quite a bore.

Early Tiva was when Tony was the king-pin, and Ziva was trying to prove herself worthy (to Tony, we all knew she was a better agent)."
Not all of us apparently. I never saw Ziva as trying to prove herself to Tony since she has always been very confident in her abilities. More like she loved to flirt with him and was always trying to get his attention.

I was not very taken with this episode and found myself actually losing attention along the way. I did enjoy the very end however. McGee thought that Tony was just kidding around at first but Tony actually had a very good take on who was doing the credit card theft. Kid with osteoporosis turned out to be a kid with an elderly landlord who apparently let him into mcGee's apartment.

Loved seeing the two of them leave with the kid for a night out. Very cute. This is the Tim and Tony interaction that I like. And I was surprised to see Tony and a kid/teenager get along - haven't seen that since the kid from Lost and Found episode. Most of the time, Tony has a hard time relating to kids.
0  out of 1 found this valuable. Do you?    
marion612
marion612
41. RE: Chat about episode 8.13 Freedom here!
Feb 2 2011, 2:43 AM EST | Post edited: Feb 2 2011, 2:43 AM EST
I didn't like it much, the case was not that interesting to me , I don't like Tiva moments and I hated the steal McGee's identity again. It seemed particularly stupid to have that (again) just after we were told that they can work at night (and we have seen them numerous times working odd hours) . I know they like to humiliate McGee and tell us it is fun but the kid should have been prosecuted not rewarded. I know this is not the real world but for once , just once couldn't McGee be angry that crap always happen to him. Why can't anything good happen to the guys? 2  out of 3 found this valuable. Do you?    

FFFrog
42. RE: Chat about episode 8.13 Freedom here!
Feb 2 2011, 3:03 AM EST | Post edited: Feb 2 2011, 3:03 AM EST
"I didn't like it much, the case was not that interesting to me , I don't like Tiva moments and I hated the steal McGee's identity again. It seemed particularly stupid to have that (again) just after we were told that they can work at night (and we have seen them numerous times working odd hours) . I know they like to humiliate McGee and tell us it is fun but the kid should have been prosecuted not rewarded. I know this is not the real world but for once , just once couldn't McGee be angry that crap always happen to him. Why can't anything good happen to the guys? "
Criminal or recklass behaviour treated as a joke is pretty standard fair of late. As is the humiliation of characters over things they should be totally capable about.
1  out of 2 found this valuable. Do you?    
marion612
marion612
43. RE: Chat about episode 8.13 Freedom here!
Feb 2 2011, 3:07 AM EST | Post edited: Feb 2 2011, 3:07 AM EST
"Criminal or recklass behaviour treated as a joke is pretty standard fair of late. As is the humiliation of characters over things they should be totally capable about. "
I don't remember a criminal targetting Tony, Ziva Abby or Gibbs for an offense which could send him in jail for up to 5 years and then have the "victim" treat him to a fun evening out on their dime. It was not fun or rather it would not have been fun if it was not done on McGee.
Do you find this valuable?    
weatherlywatcher49
weatherlywatcher49
44. RE: Chat about episode 8.13 Freedom here!
Feb 2 2011, 3:11 AM EST | Post edited: Feb 2 2011, 3:11 AM EST
"I didn't like it much, the case was not that interesting to me , I don't like Tiva moments and I hated the steal McGee's identity again. It seemed particularly stupid to have that (again) just after we were told that they can work at night (and we have seen them numerous times working odd hours) . I know they like to humiliate McGee and tell us it is fun but the kid should have been prosecuted not rewarded. I know this is not the real world but for once , just once couldn't McGee be angry that crap always happen to him. Why can't anything good happen to the guys? "
Yeah, the somebody stealing McGee's identity is getting as old as Tony being accused of murder.

I have noticed that McGee has been put out there lately as the one that is getting humiliated now that they have toned it down with Tony some. My question is this - why does anyone have to be made to look silly in order to get a laugh? I don't get it.

As far as the kid is concerned, I think he was actually trying to help McGee in a weird way - as he said trying to get him a life. From a kid's point of view, I am sure he thought McGee's life needed some spicing up because to most kids a responsible adult is dull. And I think that Mcgee understood it and let it go even though he was upset about it.

As to your question about why anything good can't happen to the guys - I've been wondering that same thing for a long time now.

While I appreciated NCIS tackling such a hard topic, I just could not get interested in the show like I usually do. I don't know why but I found my mind wandering several times during the show which rarely happens. Maybe I was just too tired from moving, who knows.
Do you find this valuable?    

FFFrog
45. RE: Chat about episode 8.13 Freedom here!
Feb 2 2011, 3:24 AM EST | Post edited: Feb 2 2011, 3:24 AM EST
"I don't remember a criminal targetting Tony, Ziva Abby or Gibbs for an offense which could send him in jail for up to 5 years and then have the "victim" treat him to a fun evening out on their dime. It was not fun or rather it would not have been fun if it was not done on McGee.
"
Ziva's assualt springs imediatly to mind. McGee and Zvia's recklesness in turning off the sound when they were providing backup also. Though I don't think this is the place to discuss these in detail. The point I'm trying to make is that, where the writers are looking for a laugh, they don't worry overly about the overall consequences of the behaviour.
0  out of 1 found this valuable. Do you?    
sueKay87
sueKay87
46. RE: Chat about episode 8.13 Freedom here!
Feb 2 2011, 3:56 AM EST | Post edited: Feb 2 2011, 3:56 AM EST
Donegal should pronounced 'Donnygaul' Do you find this valuable?    
marion612
marion612
47. RE: Chat about episode 8.13 Freedom here!
Feb 2 2011, 4:17 AM EST | Post edited: Feb 2 2011, 4:17 AM EST
"Ziva's assualt springs imediatly to mind. McGee and Zvia's recklesness in turning off the sound when they were providing backup also. Though I don't think this is the place to discuss these in detail. The point I'm trying to make is that, where the writers are looking for a laugh, they don't worry overly about the overall consequences of the behaviour."
In a way yes but at least you didn't have McGee commenting on how good it was for Tony to have been assaulted by Ziva (and then McGee fans saying how great and helping McGee was).
I think that it was what bothered me both : the kid stealing 10 grands from him and then Tony rewarding him was supposed to be seen as a good thing for McGee.
1  out of 1 found this valuable. Do you?    

FFFrog
48. RE: Chat about episode 8.13 Freedom here!
Feb 2 2011, 5:39 AM EST | Post edited: Feb 2 2011, 5:39 AM EST
"In a way yes but at least you didn't have McGee commenting on how good it was for Tony to have been assaulted by Ziva (and then McGee fans saying how great and helping McGee was).
I think that it was what bothered me both : the kid stealing 10 grands from him and then Tony rewarding him was supposed to be seen as a good thing for McGee."
I guess I'm just seeing as the same old pattern repeating again and again. Ziva was, after all, rewarded with a citizenship. And McGee and Ziva faced no consequences for their recent dereliciton of duty. Other than the obvious case, and not always even then, we are very rarely seeing people actually appreciate the consquences of their actions. Even Ziva was shown to be empathising with the victim of abuse rather than the possessor of an uncontrolled temper.
0  out of 1 found this valuable. Do you?    
rosecake
rosecake
49. RE: Chat about episode 8.13 Freedom here!
Feb 2 2011, 6:53 AM EST | Post edited: Feb 2 2011, 8:08 AM EST
Good Tony. Good Tony and the kid (finally!). Good Tony and McGee (finally!). Some good team scenes. Some really funny moments. Great ending (I felt as in the old good times *sigh*).
I closed my eyes and ears on Tiva scenes (I agree with sueKay).

All in all a nice episode, but not much more. It looked like an interlude waiting for something important. jmo
Do you find this valuable?    
Ncis-Addict
Ncis-Addict
50. RE: Chat about episode 8.13 Freedom here!
Feb 2 2011, 10:21 AM EST | Post edited: Feb 2 2011, 10:21 AM EST
This was a episode that I throughly enjoyed, I liked all the team scenes and banter between the characters. It was like a normal, stand alone episode.
I hated that they let the kid go free, what he did was against the law, it was a crime, it was fraud. They should have charged him!!! Instead, he steals ten thousand dollars, and they let him go free and treat him to a game, that kid would grow up to be a criminal and end up behind bars, it would serve him right!! The writers shouldn't have wrote McGee and Tony to let him get away with it. If that was me, I would charge him to the fullest extent of the law and ensured he was persecuted for his crime.

I really don't see how Tony was jealous, it's like Tony can't talk about Ray without someone thinking he's jealous. Tony started the Ray talk saying "I bet Renaissance Ray don't know his way around a pool table" - just because he said that and Ziva replied something (I don't remember what) Tony is jealous?! give me a break! It's you guys who "see" Tony as being jealous when he mentions Ray. And that's silly, cause he can mention Ray without getting jealous, and he did mention him without getting jealous. Everybody just simply decided that Tony got jealous because Ray was mentioned.

Anyways, this was a good episode, enjoyed it very much.
2  out of 3 found this valuable. Do you?    
rosecake
rosecake
52. RE: Chat about episode 8.13 Freedom here!
Feb 2 2011, 10:37 AM EST | Post edited: Feb 2 2011, 10:37 AM EST
"This was a episode that I throughly enjoyed, I liked all the team scenes and banter between the characters. It was like a normal, stand alone episode.
I hated that they let the kid go free, what he did was against the law, it was a crime, it was fraud. They should have charged him!!! Instead, he steals ten thousand dollars, and they let him go free and treat him to a game, that kid would grow up to be a criminal and end up behind bars, it would serve him right!! The writers shouldn't have wrote McGee and Tony to let him get away with it. If that was me, I would charge him to the fullest extent of the law and ensured he was persecuted for his crime.

I really don't see how Tony was jealous, it's like Tony can't talk about Ray without someone thinking he's jealous. Tony started the Ray talk saying "I bet Renaissance Ray don't know his way around a pool table" - just because he said that and Ziva replied something (I don't remember what) Tony is jealous?! give me a break! It's you guys who "see" Tony as being..."
Well, if TPTB let Gibbs' MIL go free after the murderer of an innocent man (I know that he was a really bad guy, but he has nothing to do with Shannon and Kelly's death, so hadn't to pay for that specific crime) they can let go free anyone else and especially a kid that I'm sure will give Tim all money back. jmo

So it's not just me that find the 'Tony-always-jelous-of-every-man-that-looks-at-Ziva'' theme old, senseless and stale. Good :)

I really liked Tony and McGee in this episode... good old times, how I miss you!!!
Finally they let Tony get along with a kid. I've never understood why they said the opposite.
Do you find this valuable?    
tara_persad
tara_persad
55. RE: Chat about episode 8.13 Freedom here!
Feb 2 2011, 11:17 AM EST | Post edited: Feb 2 2011, 1:31 PM EST
"To me Tony should have to answer that call as McGee should have answered him in GP. I think that the author used this ''plot'' again, just to give Tony a small revenge (silly) as she used McGee's money stolen from his bank account again (second or third times? I do not remember). jmo
A lack of fantasy?! "
I think Tony not answering was like McGee not answering, sort of a silly revenge thing. Rose what do you mean by "as she used McGee's money stolen from his bank account again" I don't know what you are talking about.
Do you find this valuable?    
weatherlywatcher49
weatherlywatcher49
57. RE: Chat about episode 8.13 Freedom here!
Feb 2 2011, 11:27 AM EST | Post edited: Feb 2 2011, 11:27 AM EST
"But as Tony said he knew why McGee was calling (maybe he texted something like ''I need you sign my repoert'') while in GP, Tim didn't know why Tony was callig, because as he said he didn't even check his phone.
I think the author used this ''plot'' again, just to give Tony a small/funny ''revenge'' as she used McGee's money stolen from his bank account again (second or third times? I do not remember). jmo
A lack of fantasy?! "
Yes, that McGee had his identity stolen plot line is getting a little old due to overuse - how many times does thqt make now? 3 or 4?
Do you find this valuable?    
rosecake
rosecake
58. RE: Chat about episode 8.13 Freedom here!
Feb 2 2011, 11:27 AM EST | Post edited: Feb 2 2011, 11:34 AM EST
"I think Tony not answering was like McGee not answering, sort of a silly revenge thing. Rose what do you mean by "as she used McGee's money stolen from his bank account again" I don't know what you are talking about."
I meant that this is not the first time that someone steale McGee's money identity and money from his bank account. It happened at least twice.
Do you find this valuable?    
tonysmel
tonysmel
59. RE: Chat about episode 8.13 Freedom here!
Feb 2 2011, 11:35 AM EST | Post edited: Feb 2 2011, 11:35 AM EST
"The treatment of Tony in Tiva scenes is the biggest reason I don't like Tiva anymore!"
And the sad thing for me, speaking as a pro-Tiva, is that I've become less and less enamored with it, for just that reason. Was I the only one who saw that Tony looked like he was about to cry when he mentioned being a pool shark in the 90's, and Ziva laughed and made it quite clear it was because she felt he was "old"? I mean, the guy is already going through a life crisis, and obviously depressed about aging some. So why would Ziva find it "amusing" to laugh at his age? Just confuses me and makes me feel very "Team Tony" at the moment.
0  out of 1 found this valuable. Do you?    

luckybc
60. RE: Chat about episode 8.13 Freedom here!
Feb 2 2011, 11:40 AM EST | Post edited: Feb 2 2011, 11:40 AM EST
"And the sad thing for me, speaking as a pro-Tiva, is that I've become less and less enamored with it, for just that reason. Was I the only one who saw that Tony looked like he was about to cry when he mentioned being a pool shark in the 90's, and Ziva laughed and made it quite clear it was because she felt he was "old"? I mean, the guy is already going through a life crisis, and obviously depressed about aging some. So why would Ziva find it "amusing" to laugh at his age? Just confuses me and makes me feel very "Team Tony" at the moment."
yeah, i totally agree with you. i'm pro-tiva as well, and as i mentioned earlier in this thread, i hate the way the PTB write tony and ziva sometimes. they usually write ziva like that, smug and saying hurtful comments. she was so kind with georgia--where is that compassion when she speaks with tony? i'm not a ziva-basher, there ARE a few times that she says just the right things to him, but they are just few and far between.

btw, there were two references to tony on the baltimore pd last night--the first as pool shark and the second when he talked about identity theft. foreshadowing to the origin episode perhaps?
Do you find this valuable?    
le_bibliothecaire
le_bibliothecaire
61. RE: Chat about episode 8.13 Freedom here!
Feb 2 2011, 11:44 AM EST | Post edited: Feb 2 2011, 11:44 AM EST
"Yes, that McGee had his identity stolen plot line is getting a little old due to overuse - how many times does thqt make now? 3 or 4?"
I did like the low-tech "twist" this time--that it was ID theft with no computer hacking involved. McGee scoffed, saying Tony never worked "Cyber crimes" before, but McGee, like so many other people, have become so engrossed with the tech toys and worrying about their identity being stolen online that they do not bother to worry about their mail, what they toss out with their garbage, varying their schedules and habits, etc. McGee was not looking past the fact that no one had breached his firewall. I love to see Tony (and Gibbs) reach back into their bag of "cop tricks" and experience to solve cases, as it is more the connecting of dots, creative solutions , and intuition that I find more interesting.

As for prosecuting the kid, I suspect they will not simply reward him and let him go, but will at least let him know what could happen to him if he continues to do these things. So many young people do stupid things, then go to prison for lesser crimes but end up becoming more hardcore in prison (or even juvenile detention), so maybe they were trying to spare putting another kid who'd just done something stupid in the system. I agree they need to do something, but I suspect they had a plan to at least try to get through to the kid. And don't forget, McGee did not want to press charges against the girlfriend who stole his information and ran up of $60,000 on his credit cards.
Do you find this valuable?    
sueKay87
sueKay87
62. RE: Chat about episode 8.13 Freedom here!
Feb 2 2011, 11:57 AM EST | Post edited: Feb 2 2011, 11:57 AM EST
"And the sad thing for me, speaking as a pro-Tiva, is that I've become less and less enamored with it, for just that reason. Was I the only one who saw that Tony looked like he was about to cry when he mentioned being a pool shark in the 90's, and Ziva laughed and made it quite clear it was because she felt he was "old"? I mean, the guy is already going through a life crisis, and obviously depressed about aging some. So why would Ziva find it "amusing" to laugh at his age? Just confuses me and makes me feel very "Team Tony" at the moment."
Yup!

I used to be pro-Tiva, but the more scenes I see with 'jealous' 'old' Tony and smug superior Ziva, the more I dislike the entire notion!

I guess I'm anti-Tiva now, and normally I'm a huge, massive shipper for shows I watch...Seriously...I've written like 150,000 words of ship fic for one of my fave couples on another show!
Do you find this valuable?    
tonysmel
tonysmel
63. RE: Chat about episode 8.13 Freedom here!
Feb 2 2011, 12:22 PM EST | Post edited: Feb 2 2011, 12:22 PM EST
sueKay, I know, it's sad when you sour on a a character or ship you once liked.
On a more positive note, with two mentions by Tony of his Baltimore cop days in Freedom, I'm starting to feel that they're setting up the Tony-origin ep, which makes me excited. I also wonder if the continued theme of Tony having issues with age will all lead to something coming to a head, either in the therapist ep, origin ep, or finale?
Do you find this valuable?    
Previous | 1 2 3 4 5 | Next > Last

Related Content

  (what's this?Related ContentThanks to keyword tags, links to related pages and threads are added to the bottom of your pages. Up to 15 links are shown, determined by matching tags and by how recently the content was updated; keeping the most current at the top. Share your feedback on Wetpaint Central.)