Sign in or 

|
rkent36 |
40. RE: TIVA - THE OBSESSION
Aug 28 2009, 5:43 PM EDT
Prior to season 6, I would have classified myself as a Tony/Ziva fan ... but with the way the two characters were written through season 6 (especially Ziva's outright criminal behavior in the last four eps), I find it hard to believe that they can return to being FRIENDS, let alone get involved in a romantic relationship. Of course, I'm also evidently in the minority in that I pretty much loathed this season (out of the 25 episodes aired, I only *really* liked 3) and no real plans to actually watch the new show live. I'll DVR the eps and get around to watching them (maybe) when I'm bored or something. And based on the few spoilers coming out, I'm less excited than ever before (especially since I never had any real desire to see the Tony/Ziva thing be more than subtext or at least a tertiary part of the show.)That said, there are just as many insanely aggressive Other Shippers/Anti-shippers out there who can be just as vitriolic and downright mean as some TIVA people (Lord, I hate that cutesy name.) I think there are simply more of the aggressive Tony/Ziva people than the others (simple law of averages), hence it seems to non-Tony/Ziva people that ALL Tony/Ziva people are raving lunatics. In my experience, EVERY group, whether it's a religion or a political party or a group of particular shippers, is defined by its most vocal minority. Fans comes from Fanatics, after all. 2 out of 2 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
NCIS_rules |
41. RE: TIVA - THE OBSESSION
Aug 29 2009, 12:47 AM EDT
"Prior to season 6, I would have classified myself as a Tony/Ziva fan ... but with the way the two characters were written through season 6 (especially Ziva's outright criminal behavior in the last four eps), I find it hard to believe that they can return to being FRIENDS, let alone get involved in a romantic relationship. Of course, I'm also evidently in the minority in that I pretty much loathed this season (out of the 25 episodes aired, I only *really* liked 3) and no real plans to actually watch the new show live. I'll DVR the eps and get around to watching them (maybe) when I'm bored or something. And based on the few spoilers coming out, I'm less excited than ever before (especially since I never had any real desire to see the Tony/Ziva thing be more than subtext or at least a tertiary part of the show.)I just think it would be bad for the show, but I do like both characters, although I am not sure how they are going to overcome their sever snoring problems (re-watch the Under Covers episode in case you forgot). And I guess after I found out there is a creepy group of GABBY fans out there, I guess Tiva is not so bad in comparison, and I could at least live with it. I am not going to be mean to Tiva fans, I am sort of a fan, I like all the flirting and stuff, but Tony will lose that whole womanizer side he has, like he did when he was with Jeanne Benoit Do you find this valuable? |
|
NCIS_rules |
42. RE: TIVA - THE OBSESSION
Aug 29 2009, 12:58 AM EDT
| Post edited: Aug 29 2009, 1:00 AM EDT
The question you really have to ask yourself: Is the show better if DiNozzo loses that chauvanistic, womanizing side, that so many of the jokes come from? If you like nice Tony, then he and Ziva should hook up. Remember when he and Jeanne were dating? I really liked Jeanne, but if he and Ziva were that way, would you get tired of it? I like Ziva being a total badass, and Tony being a chauvanistic buffoon, but can also be a good guy some of the time. If Tony was nice all the time, would we still like him as much? The fact that he suprises us with his acts of kindness and caring, endears him to us, because we know he is capable of being a better person, so we are rooting for him, but if he turns smitten, nice guy, then we lose that thing we have been rooting for, the same way we lose the idea of Tony+Ziva hooking up, once they actually do, then what is there to root for with Tony? NCIS is a crime drama, not Grey's Anatomy, where they are always doing everything they can to keep it a soap opera, it is a cheap way to get ratings, and I hope NCIS never becomes that type of show. Because that is what happens once main characters start dating.
0
out of
2 found this valuable.
Do you?
|
|
as524 |
43. RE: TIVA - THE OBSESSION
Aug 29 2009, 12:14 PM EDT
While I enjoyed the glimpses of the Tony we saw with Jeanne, I don't think that liking *that* Tony means that he & Ziva should hook up. Neither Jeanne nor Ziva are the right person for Tony. I won't discuss Jeanne because this isn't the thread but Ziva is just so wrong as a romantic interest on so many levels I think I'd end up writing a novel trying to list them all.
3
out of
3 found this valuable.
Do you?
|
|
Det.Beckett |
44. RE: TIVA - THE OBSESSION
Aug 29 2009, 11:00 PM EDT
Before S6, I probably wouldn't have stood for the idea of Tiva, although I always thought they had good chemistry, but now the idea doesn't seem so bad. However, the hints given by TPTB have me pretty nervous. While if at the end of the series they were to end up together I would be happy, it takes amazingly good writing to pull off any inter-team relationship mid-series. And although I love the NCIS writing, I've seen so many shows ruined by such complications that I would hate for NCIS to follow the same route. My two greatest fears: 1) They get together and one has to leave the team and/or there are a bunch of episodes where they have to hide it from Gibbs. 2) They don't get together at all and TPTB were just pulling the legs of fans all along. Seems pretty cruel to do to the die-hard 'shippers. As for the fans themselves...I wouldn't know too much about Tiva 'shippers per se, but I know from other fandoms that a lot of 'shippers and anti-'shippers seem to be some of the most passionate and vitriolic fans. I don't know why that is, but it can make it uncomfortable for other fans at times.
1
out of
2 found this valuable.
Do you?
|
|
LJFan |
45. RE: TIVA - THE OBSESSION
Aug 30 2009, 12:44 AM EDT
"The question you really have to ask yourself: Is the show better if DiNozzo loses that chauvanistic, womanizing side, that so many of the jokes come from? If you like nice Tony, then he and Ziva should hook up. Remember when he and Jeanne were dating? I really liked Jeanne, but if he and Ziva were that way, would you get tired of it? I like Ziva being a total badass, and Tony being a chauvanistic buffoon, but can also be a good guy some of the time. If Tony was nice all the time, would we still like him as much? The fact that he suprises us with his acts of kindness and caring, endears him to us, because we know he is capable of being a better person, so we are rooting for him, but if he turns smitten, nice guy, then we lose that thing we have been rooting for, the same way we lose the idea of Tony+Ziva hooking up, once they actually do, then what is there to root for with Tony? NCIS is a crime drama, not Grey's Anatomy, where they are always doing everything they can to keep it a soap opera, it is a cheap way to get ratings, and I hope NCIS never becomes that type of show. Because that is what happens once main characters start dating."Well said....Thank you! Do you find this valuable? |
|
rkent36 |
46. RE: TIVA - THE OBSESSION
Aug 30 2009, 4:19 AM EDT
"Before S6, I probably wouldn't have stood for the idea of Tiva, although I always thought they had good chemistry, but now the idea doesn't seem so bad. "Seriously? Wow. This season utterly destroyed any interest I have in the ship, what with the complete disintegration of their relationship. I mean, if I'm Tony, there's no way in hell I'd EVER go into the field with a woman who just implied she would prefer that I died rather than the lying, deceptive, manipulative murderer she was sleeping with, especially if I just put my life and career on the line because I dared to try and give her the benefit of the doubt when everything is pointing to her being a mole. That would pretty much ruin ANY romantic interest I'd have in the woman. Period. Of course, I'm biased in that I frankly don't much like Ziva in the wake of the so-called "Tiva arc" starting with Legend I and the (IMO) absolutely ridiculous characterization that resulted. 4 out of 4 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
jml709 |
47. RE: TIVA - THE OBSESSION
Aug 30 2009, 2:22 PM EDT
As was previously mentioned, 'Moonlighting' lost something after David and Maddie finally got together. 'Cheers' initially gained something and then lost it after Sam and Diane got together. 'Mork and Mindy' lost it when those two got together (and Jonathan Winters was their child -- seriously).I don't want to see NCIS 'jump the shark' (as it were) to have Tony and Ziva get together solely for the TIVA-obsessed fans. Remember that JAG lasted ten seasons with Harm and Mac finally deciding to get married at the very end, and then we never knew who sacrificed their career for the other (decided by a coin toss which was left unfinished). Let's hope that NCIS also makes it to 10 seasons -- something that Donald B. was hoping for at its inception. 8 out of 8 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
Det.Beckett |
48. RE: TIVA - THE OBSESSION
Aug 30 2009, 8:17 PM EDT
"Seriously? Wow. This season utterly destroyed any interest I have in the ship, what with the complete disintegration of their relationship. I mean, if I'm Tony, there's no way in hell I'd EVER go into the field with a woman who just implied she would prefer that I died rather than the lying, deceptive, manipulative murderer she was sleeping with, especially if I just put my life and career on the line because I dared to try and give her the benefit of the doubt when everything is pointing to her being a mole. That would pretty much ruin ANY romantic interest I'd have in the woman. Period.My mistake, I meant S5. But I would say S6 cemented my opinion on the matter rather than making me less supportive of the 'ship. You might be being too hard on Ziva. I really doubt Ziva knew how bad Rivkin was, and after his death she wasn't thinking straight. If someone you know dies, would it really be surprising if your initial reaction isn't one of sound reason? Haven't you ever said anything cruel to a friend, even if you didn't mean it? Also I bet Ziva feels very duped right now. She talked a lot about trust, and she is probably asking herself how she could have trusted Rivkin. She wasn't listening to her gut, and she knows it. It is likely she is being far harder on herself than she is being on Tony. Tony knows this, which is why he continues trying to explain. He expects it to get through to her eventually, and he wants her to be clear that he was only trying to help. Honestly, I kind of agree with jml709's post: it would be nice if at the end of the series they got together, but any time before that might make things way too complicated. 2 out of 2 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
rkent36 |
49. RE: TIVA - THE OBSESSION
Aug 30 2009, 9:19 PM EDT
"You might be being too hard on Ziva. I really doubt Ziva knew how bad Rivkin was, and after his death she wasn't thinking straight. If someone you know dies, would it really be surprising if your initial reaction isn't one of sound reason? Haven't you ever said anything cruel to a friend, even if you didn't mean it? Also I bet Ziva feels very duped right now. She talked a lot about trust, and she is probably asking herself how she could have trusted Rivkin. She wasn't listening to her gut, and she knows it. It is likely she is being far harder on herself than she is being on Tony. Tony knows this, which is why he continues trying to explain. He expects it to get through to her eventually, and he wants her to be clear that he was only trying to help. "Some things cannot be unsaid. Yeah, I get the whole 'saying things you regret in the heat of the moment,' but it's less what she said and more what she DID. Not only did she tell him those things, but she also assaulted him (while he was injured), stuck a live weapon in his chest, and then later tried to have him transferred off the team because she wasn't comfortable with him. Tony gave her the benefit of the doubt and she tried to screw him over for it (which violates Gibbs' Rule #1.) So unless season 7 has her pleading for forgiveness and apologizing for being an utter idiot (which I doubt, 'cause they're more likely to have Tony blame himself even though he was in the right.) The problem stems heavily with the writing of Ziva. She's supposed to be a highly trained covert operative capable of detecting deceit and lies ... yet, once again, a man close to her is able to dupe her (Ari, Tony in s4, now Rivkin AND her dad.) That means she flat out sucks as a spy. *shrug* To each their own, I guess. 5 out of 5 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
Det.Beckett |
50. RE: TIVA - THE OBSESSION
Aug 30 2009, 9:39 PM EDT
"Some things cannot be unsaid. Yeah, I get the whole 'saying things you regret in the heat of the moment,' but it's less what she said and more what she DID. Not only did she tell him those things, but she also assaulted him (while he was injured), stuck a live weapon in his chest, and then later tried to have him transferred off the team because she wasn't comfortable with him. Tony gave her the benefit of the doubt and she tried to screw him over for it (which violates Gibbs' Rule #1.) So unless season 7 has her pleading for forgiveness and apologizing for being an utter idiot (which I doubt, 'cause they're more likely to have Tony blame himself even though he was in the right.)I agree that when she attacked him she was out of line. but I also think if Tony had been smart he would have left her alone to sulk. If I recall correctly, she didn't seek him out, he sought her out. Do you really think she was trying to have him transferred? When she put that ultimatum to Gibbs, she couldn't really have been thinking he would choose her over DiNozzi. So I think she was simply telling him that there was no way for her to stay, and that she would be better off in Israel. I agree with you that Tony was right. He was and it is that simple. Ari duped everyone, including Gibbs, which says a lot more about his character than about anyone else. Did Rivkin really fool her? She was smart enough to know he had to be taken care of, thus her call to Mossad. As for her dad, that one is instinctual. But how did Tony dupe her in S4? 1 out of 3 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
rkent36 |
51. RE: TIVA - THE OBSESSION
Aug 30 2009, 10:31 PM EDT
"Do you really think she was trying to have him transferred? "Brennan said point-blank that she WAS. Of course, given his apparent propensity for retconning, that means nothing thus far. As to Tony & s4, he was on an undercover operation (the Benoit thing) and out of ANYONE on the team, Ziva should have been able to figure that out somewhere around 4x05 or x06 instead of buying the whole "could he be dying?" or the "new" girlfriend thing. Again, a failing in regards to the writing. 3 out of 3 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
Det.Beckett |
52. RE: TIVA - THE OBSESSION
Aug 30 2009, 11:09 PM EDT
"Brennan said point-blank that she WAS. Of course, given his apparent propensity for retconning, that means nothing thus far.Sorry, I didn't know that Brennan said that. S4: Why Ziva and not Gibbs? Again, this is a time when everyone failed to notice the signs because they didn't want to. Ziva knew that Tony was doing something for the director, but why would that mission have anything to do with his girlfriend. And if you notice in "Trojan Horse", Ziva was concerned about Tony, but she let Ducky talk her out of following her gut because she didn't want her concern to be misconstrued as jealousy. If she'd gone ahead, maybe things wouldn't have gotten so messy in the end. 1 out of 2 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
rkent36 |
53. RE: TIVA - THE OBSESSION
Aug 31 2009, 5:05 AM EDT
"S4: Why Ziva and not Gibbs? "Gibbs wasn't at 100% because he was still recovering from the amnesia injury. Her failure to put two and two together, given her ostensible training as a covert agent. her experience with Jenny Shepard, and the fact that NCIS is, after all, an intelligence agency was just kind of dumb, particularly since "Kill Ari" established that she had profiled the members of Gibbs team and would know that DiNozzo has done undercover work before. 1 out of 1 found this valuable. Do you? |
|
Det.Beckett |
54. RE: TIVA - THE OBSESSION
Sep 1 2009, 5:24 PM EDT
"Gibbs wasn't at 100% because he was still recovering from the amnesia injury. Her failure to put two and two together, given her ostensible training as a covert agent. her experience with Jenny Shepard, and the fact that NCIS is, after all, an intelligence agency was just kind of dumb, particularly since "Kill Ari" established that she had profiled the members of Gibbs team and would know that DiNozzo has done undercover work before."I don't buy that Gibbs wasn't in a better position than Ziva, after all he had known DiNozzo a lot longer. But that aside, the team does realize he is doing something for Dir. Shepard, but I still don't know why they should have connected that Jeanne. Do you find this valuable? |
|
BrigadierOutCold |
55. The Tiva Rebellion Movement
Nov 2 2009, 3:03 PM EST
Hey,Look, I was flicking through Tiva stuff on the internet and found this thread. I completely agree with what you've said here, and just wanted to express my relief that other people feel this way. My friend and I created the Tiva Rebellion Movement. It's not got many members, but it's just a bunch of people who don't ship Tiva and would really really prefer it didn't happen. Also just to chat and stuff, as is the very nature of forums. ;D Tiva shippers are also welcome to have a bit of debate around the place - I don't mind fighting my corner. :P We like to mess around and use military language, but over-aggressiveness will not be tolerated. I'm friends with plenty Tiva shippers and they're perfectly pleasant intelligent people. Anyhoo, love to see you there. Brig. Do you find this valuable? |
|
Mulchahy |
56. RE: The Tiva Rebellion Movement
Nov 26 2009, 11:16 PM EST
I find the idea horrifying. Like others have said, it would ruin the show. I hope Brennan is smart enough to realize this and to forget those fans. Sure throw in a little flirting once in awhile to keep some fans happy but when Ziva kissed Tony on the CHEEK I was the happiest person. That moment was very nervracking for me. I don't know if anyone on the show really needs a relationship anyways. Gibbs' never work out, and the McGee ones are a little awkward. I can only think of bringing Jeanne back and she would have to be an idiot to start dating Tony again considering all that happened. Plus Ziva and McGee have been being mean to him lately causing me to believe that there is no interest between characters. Lets keep it that way. I love both characters just not together.
1
out of
1 found this valuable.
Do you?
|
|
bellswebster |
57. RE: TIVA - THE OBSESSION
Dec 5 2009, 7:37 AM EST
"As was previously mentioned, 'Moonlighting' lost something after David and Maddie finally got together. 'Cheers' initially gained something and then lost it after Sam and Diane got together. 'Mork and Mindy' lost it when those two got together (and Jonathan Winters was their child -- seriously).We want this to be better than 10 seasons... Do you find this valuable? |
|
bellswebster |
58. RE: The Tiva Rebellion Movement
Dec 5 2009, 7:41 AM EST
"I find the idea horrifying. Like others have said, it would ruin the show. I hope Brennan is smart enough to realize this and to forget those fans. Sure throw in a little flirting once in awhile to keep some fans happy but when Ziva kissed Tony on the CHEEK I was the happiest person. That moment was very nervracking for me. I don't know if anyone on the show really needs a relationship anyways. Gibbs' never work out, and the McGee ones are a little awkward. I can only think of bringing Jeanne back and she would have to be an idiot to start dating Tony again considering all that happened. Plus Ziva and McGee have been being mean to him lately causing me to believe that there is no interest between characters. Lets keep it that way. I love both characters just not together."*Applauds Mulchahy*...WELL said...perhaps not the bit about Jeanne...she lied to Tony about who her father really was. Do you find this valuable? |
|
yichelle |
59. RE: The Tiva Rebellion Movement
Dec 6 2009, 4:07 AM EST
"*Applauds Mulchahy*...WELL said...perhaps not the bit about Jeanne...she lied to Tony about who her father really was. "Hi Bellswebster, I don't think Jeanne knew what her father did for a living cos when Jeanne asked tony why did he lie to her, he tells her to ask her father about it. Do you find this valuable? |